It all started when I was re-organizing my lip products and I realized a couple of them where just like another.MAC cremesheen lipstick - Shy girl/ NYX round lipstick- Pumpkin pie
ShyGirl Vs pumpkin Pie: They are almost identical on the lips, if anything maybe the Mac one has a bit more pink in it that the NYX one, but besides that they are about the same.
ShyGirl Vs pumpkin Pie: They are almost identical on the lips, if anything maybe the Mac one has a bit more pink in it that the NYX one, but besides that they are about the same.
MAC lipglass-Mimi(L.E. from Hello kitty collection)/NYX Megashine lipgloss-Perfect
Mimi Vs. Perfect: I LOVE Mimi and have been looking for a dupe for it forever, since it was limited edition. So when I realized that they were so similar you can just imagine how pleasantly surprised I was! Not only will I have this color that I adore forever and ever, but it is much cheaper than the MAC. I must say that Perfect is a bit more sheer than Mimi but since I wear them over a lipstick most of the time, it doesn't bother me much.
ELF mineral lipstick-Runway pink/ YSL Rouge Volupte-#1 Nude beige
Swatched:
MAC Shy Girl/NYX Pumpkin Pie.... MAC Mimi/NYX Perfect... YSL Nude Beige/ELF RunwayPink
So that is it! If you all have any dupes you know about let me know!!Runway Pink Vs. Nude Beige: The YSL is my all time fave lipstick, about 2 months ago I purchased the ELF, I really liked it and wore it for a moth straight, but never gave much thought to the color. I just slathered it on daily and went on about my day. Well then while going through my lipsticks I realized they were fairly similar, but it wasn't 'till I swatched them side by side that I came to the conclusion that they were indeed the same color!!! Now the normal person would decide not to ever repurchase the super expensive one and just stick to the $5 one....well not me. See, one of the reasons I adore my Rouge volupte is because of the texture/consistency of it and the ELF just doesn't compare. Don't get me wrong, it's a great product, it's just that the YSL is THAT amazing, if you have ever tried a RVolupte you know exactly what I mean!
Swatched:
MAC Shy Girl/NYX Pumpkin Pie.... MAC Mimi/NYX Perfect... YSL Nude Beige/ELF RunwayPink
After this "discoveries", I decide to go through my entire make up stash and look for more dupes. And indeed more I found:
NARS Sheer Glow Vs. Neutrogena Healthy skin: Read my comparison 2 posts below. Although healthy skin broke me out, I'd recommend it to anyone who has tried a Neutrogena foundation in the past and hasn't reacted badly to it. Because it is just like the Nars and so much cheaper!
I have a Milani Shadow Wear Quad in Touch of Brown and two of the shades in it are very similar to another two of my MAC shadows. Sardun1 compared the darker shade in this quad (bottom right) to MAC Satin Taupe, but since I do not own it I cannot vouch for that.
Milani Touch of Brown (bottom left) Vs. MAC Woodwinked: The Milani is a bit more sheer than than the MAC but a great cheaper alternative.
Top:UD Zero/Bottom:Milani LiquifEye BlackNARS Sheer Glow Vs. Neutrogena Healthy skin: Read my comparison 2 posts below. Although healthy skin broke me out, I'd recommend it to anyone who has tried a Neutrogena foundation in the past and hasn't reacted badly to it. Because it is just like the Nars and so much cheaper!
I have a Milani Shadow Wear Quad in Touch of Brown and two of the shades in it are very similar to another two of my MAC shadows. Sardun1 compared the darker shade in this quad (bottom right) to MAC Satin Taupe, but since I do not own it I cannot vouch for that.
MAC Retrospeck Vs. Milani Touch of Brown (top left color): if anything the Milani one is silkier, smoother and more pigmented than RetrospeckTop: Milani/Bottom: MAC Retrospeck
Top: MAC Wooodwinked/ Bottom: Milani
L'oreal Hip Pigment in Restless VS MAC Pigment in Vanilla: These are so similar that I forgot which one was which in the swatch picture below!
Sorry don't know!!
Milani LiquifEye liner in Black Vs. Urban Decay 24/7 liner in Zero: I used to think the UD liner was the best thing since sliced bread, until I met LiquifEye! It is a more intense black which I didn't think was possible and it lasts longer...oh yea and did I mention it's super cheap...'cause it is!!
The last one is one that I wasn't going t include since I don't own what it's a dupe for but, so many people have said that it is, and I love it. It is the ELF HD powder (from their studio line) and it is supposed be the same as the MUFE HD powder. Like I said, I don't own the latter, but my ELF does everything the MUFE one promises to do. It sets my foundation without looking heavy or cakey. If you have tried the MUFE one let me know what you think about it.
Love, Esme